This vendor is popular with couples. Start a conversation
Did you like this vendor?
1 / 43
About
On WeddingWire since 2015
Mitchel’s Cake & Dessert Co. is a bakery based in Whitby, Ontario, that specializes in designing beautiful and delicious wedding cakes. Serving Whitby and surrounding areas, this team creates cakes that look as good as they taste. Their customized designs, outstanding flavours, and highly professional staff ensure an unforgettable experience from the first meeting to the last bite.
Services Offered
With a unique selection of fillings, buttercream frostings, and delicious cake flavours, Mitchel’s Cake & Dessert Co. creates desserts that will surely delight you and your guests. You can schedule a consultation and tasting to sample your favourite flavours. Whether you want a rustic, naked cake, classic white design, or one decorated with flowers, this team can design a cake to match your vision. You can also avail of other desserts like cookies, cupcakes, and groom’s cakes.
Frequently asked questions
What types of desserts do you provide?
Cakes
Cookies
Cupcakes
Groom's cake
What services do you provide?
Consultations
Custom cake design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - private
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
Nut free
What special ingredients do you use?
Fresh fruit
Are you licensed by the health department?
Yes
What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)?
$6
Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake?
Top tier of the cake
What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)?
$3.50
What services do your prices include?
Consultation
Custom cake design
Delivery
Set up
Tasting - private
Any other questions?
Reviews for Mitchel's Cake & Dessert Co.
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.8 out of 5 rating
4.8 out of 5 rating
176 reviews
96% recommend it
Thelma Sent on 21/10/2024
4.4 out of 5 rating
Delicious Wedding Cake & Cupcakes
We ordered our wedding cake and cupcakes from Mitchell's Cakes and were very happy with the experience! The cupcakes were a big hit with our guests, and the cake itself was absolutely delicious—definitely a 10/10 for taste. The cost was also reasonable for what we ordered.
There were just a couple of small areas for improvement. I picked up the cake stand ahead of time, and while the cake and cupcakes were delivered on the day of, the stand was made of plain cardboard, which didn’t match the elegance we envisioned. We decorated it ourselves, but it looked more like a grade school art project. I would have gladly paid for a rental glass stand to elevate the presentation.
Overall, we highly recommend Mitchell's Cakes for anyone looking for delicious, well-priced desserts. A little more attention to presentation would take the experience to the next level!
There were just a couple of small areas for improvement. I picked up the cake stand ahead of time, and while the cake and cupcakes were delivered on the day of, the stand was made of plain cardboard, which didn’t match the elegance we envisioned. We decorated it ourselves, but it looked more like a grade school art project. I would have gladly paid for a rental glass stand to elevate the presentation.
Overall, we highly recommend Mitchell's Cakes for anyone looking for delicious, well-priced desserts. A little more attention to presentation would take the experience to the next level!
Nicole P. Sent on 01/01/2024
5 out of 5 rating
Dream Wedding Buttercream Wedding Cake
I've ordered several cakes from Mitchel's in the past for big life events so getting our wedding cake from them was no different. We ended up choosing a 3 tier for our main wedding cake with maple (5") , lemon with raspberry filling (8") and marble cake (12") and carrot cake without nuts (8") and cream cheese frosting for the grooms cake.
We asked for a cake large enough to serve approximately 100 guests and it was the perfect amount. Our venue did slice our cake and they were larger than a typical cake serving slice as well! The cake was absolutely delicious, great flavour and crumb to the cake especially the maple and carrot cake!
There was great communication with Brent and was prompt to answer any of my questions I had throughout the process. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious buttercream cake!
We asked for a cake large enough to serve approximately 100 guests and it was the perfect amount. Our venue did slice our cake and they were larger than a typical cake serving slice as well! The cake was absolutely delicious, great flavour and crumb to the cake especially the maple and carrot cake!
There was great communication with Brent and was prompt to answer any of my questions I had throughout the process. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a delicious buttercream cake!
Charlton Sent on 03/12/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Great cake!
Thank you so much for our amazing wedding cake! It looked amazing and tasted even better. So many options and we are enjoying it still!
Amanda W. Sent on 24/10/2023
5 out of 5 rating
So happy we went with Mitchel's Cake and Dessert Co.
Our cake by Mitchel's Cake and Dessert Company was delicious and beautiful! We received many compliments from our guests about how the cake looked and tasted fantastic. Also, we loved that we had the option to choose two different flavours for our wedding cake, which worked out perfectly since my husband and I had two different favourite flavours when we went to our tasting. The whole process of choosing a design and ordering a cake was effortless, as Mitchel’s Cake and Dessert Company handled everything from start to finish. They delivered the cake to our venue and set it up as well. We didn’t have to lift a finger! I highly recommend going with Mitchel’s Cake and Dessert Company!
Laura Sent on 16/10/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Beautiful wedding cake, delicious, and absolutely professional and amazing communication!
I cannot recommend Mitchel’s Cakes enough. They were very professional, had great and fast communication, were amazing to work with, and made/delivered the most beautiful and delicious cake for our wedding. Will be recommending them to anyone needing a cake or getting married .
Karlee Sent on 10/10/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Best Wedding Cake Ever!
Mitchel's Cakes made our wedding cake for our wedding last weekend, and it was seriously the best cake we've ever had in our lives! Each layer was a different flavour, and it was 3 tiers. It looked exactly how we wanted it too as well, and it was delivered on time. Definitely book them for your wedding or event - absolutely worth the money!
Jessica B. Sent on 20/08/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Wedding cake
The wedding cake that I ordered from them was very well lovely and was very moist.
Andree-Anne C. Sent on 30/07/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Delicious Cake!
Delicious cake! Me and my husband ordered the coconut and carrot cake from mitchels, I’m personally not a carrot cake kind of person but mitchel’s cake managed to change my mind! Everyone at the wedding wouldn’t stop getting seconds cause it was so good! And the service is amazing and delivered right on schedule!
100% recommend
100% recommend
Lynette Sent on 15/01/2023
5 out of 5 rating
Really attentive to our needs and professional
A beautiful cake and also a great delicious taste . We really enjoy our wedding cake .Thank you so much !!
Jessica F. Sent on 12/10/2022
5 out of 5 rating
Beautiful (and tasty) cake!
Our cake was exactly what we had pictured!! It had 3 layers and all different flavors.
Would definitely recommend!
Would definitely recommend!
Are you interested?
Mitchel's Cake & Dessert Co. Real Weddings
Karlee & Daniel
16 Photos · 30/Sep/2023
Vika & Haydn
7 Photos · 15/Oct/2021
Taylor & Curtis
15 Photos · 03/Oct/2020
Carrina & Dylan
22 Photos · 11/Aug/2018
Map
93 Bach Avenue L1R 2P8 Whitby (Ontario)